IFC’s appraisal considered the environmental and social management planning process and documentation for the Project and gaps, if any, between these and IFC’s requirements. Where necessary, corrective measures, intended to close these gaps within a reasonable period of time, are summarized in the paragraphs that follow and (if applicable) in an agreed Environmental and Social Action Plan (ESAP). Through implementation of these measures, the Project is expected to be designed and operated in accordance with Performance Standards objectives.
E&S Policies and Management Systems: MCSI has developed an Environmental and Social policy that is applied to its projects. In addition, for this project an overarching environmental and social policy will be established by the project company [ESAP#1]. The policy will specify that the project will comply with applicable laws and regulations and will be aligned with IFC Performance Standard 1 requirements. The policy will indicate who, within the client’s organization, will ensure conformance with the policy and be responsible for its execution.
An E&S Management Plan (ESMP) has been developed that outlines key mitigation measures identified via the ESIA process that the company will implement during the project construction and operation. The company will establish an Environmental and Social Management System (ESMS) [ESAP#2] that will (i) incorporate an E&S Policy; (ii) combine all mitigation, monitoring, and management measures from the ESIA, ESMP and the ESAP requirements, to be used throughout the Project’s life; (iii) outline the schedule, resources, and performance indicators; and (iv) define responsibilities, including organizational structure, roles, communication, and reporting needed to implement the ESMS. The ESMS will include an ESMP for early works/Limited Notice to Proceed (LNTP), Construction ESMP, an Operations ESMP, and a range of detailed sub-plans covering areas such as labor management, occupational health and safety (OHS), emergency response, environmental controls, biodiversity management, cultural heritage, and security.
Based on the archaeological survey undertaken in August 2024 and the ESIA no significant impacts on known cultural heritage are anticipated. The project has developed a Chance Find Procedure (CFP), including procedures for responding to chance finds and specific provisions for human remains. The CFP will be incorporated into the Project ESMS [ref. ESAP #2] and applicable contractor management requirements and implemented during construction and other ground-disturbing activities.
Identification of risks and impacts: A Detailed Environmental Impact Assessment (DEIA) was prepared to meet national standards. In addition, NZE has contracted an external consultant to undertake the ESIA in line with IFC Performance Standards.
Organization Capacity: E&S roles and responsibilities have been assigned at the sponsor’s level. At the project company level, a Project Environmental, Health and Safety team hasn’t been formed yet. In accordance with the ESAP#3, an E&S Manager will be appointed at the NZE level, who will be responsible for overall project’s E&S performance.
Monitoring and Review: In accordance with the ESAP#2 EHS monitoring requirements will be included in the ESMS for the construction and the operation phases of the project. The E&S staff contracted by the EPC contractor/O&M provider will be responsible for the implementation of the ESMPs, including contractors’ developed management plans and programs, monitoring actions and reporting. The company’s E&S Manager appointed as per the ESAP#4 will monitor the project E&S performance as per the ESMS.
Emergency preparedness and response: The ESIA identifies a range of emergency situations that may occur during the construction and operation phases and requires the development of project-specific emergency preparedness and response plans (EPRPs) for both phases. Project-specific EPRPs for construction and operation are yet to be finalized, and as per ESAP # 2, the Project is required to prepare and implement construction and operation-phase EPRPs in accordance with IFC PS1, covering defined emergency scenarios, roles and responsibilities, communication and evacuation procedures, emergency equipment and medical response, contractor and external emergency service coordination, staff training, and periodic drills with corrective actions tracked to closure.
For emergency scenarios involving BESS-related fires and explosions, the emergency response procedure, including any actions concerning nearby herder communities, will be informed by the BESS HAZOP, Layer of Protection Analysis (LOPA), and consequence modelling covering fire and explosion scenarios conducted during the detailed design phase. Based on the outcomes of the HAZOP and LOPA, NZE will decide if a Quantitative Risk Assessment (QRA) is required to further evaluate and quantify potential risks. These combined hazard studies, alongside any subsequent QRA, will be consolidated in a formal BESS Design Safety Basis (DSB) to demonstrate how prevention, isolation, mitigation, and emergency response are engineered into the system lifecycle [ESAP #4]. These studies will define the specialized emergency measures tailored to the remote area's limited emergency capacity and integrate them directly into the project's EPRP.
Climate change: IFC identified a medium level of climate E&S risks and impacts resulting from a changing climate, including extreme cold, extreme heat, drought, water stress and flooding. The client will manage and mitigate risks and potential adverse impacts by implementing relevant measures identified in the assessment and management plans. The client will monitor and report on their implementation.
Supply chain: The project company will develop and implement a Supply Chain Management System aligned with IFC E&S requirements [as per ESAP#5]
PS2: Labor and Working Condition:
The Project is expected to employ approximately 250-300 workers during peak construction and approximately 34 workers during operations.
Human Resources Policies and Procedures: MCSI has established corporate-level labor and workforce management policies and procedures, including an Employment and Labor Relations Policy, Code of Conduct, and Anti-Sexual harassment policy. These documents establish overarching requirements relating to workforce management, labor rights, workplace conduct, prevention of harassment, equal opportunity, and workforce welfare. NZE will develop and implement project-specific HR policies and procedures, consistent with IFC PS2 and Mongolian labor legislation [ESAP#6].
Working Conditions and Terms of Employment: The corporate frameworks include provisions relating to employment contracts, remuneration and compensation, working hours, entitlements, social insurance, fitness-for-work requirements, and workforce training. As part of ESAP#6, NZE will develop project-specific procedures governing working conditions and terms of employment applicable to direct workers, contractors, and subcontractors, including provision of documented information to workers, in a language they understand, on their rights and conditions of employment, consistent with IFC PS2 requirements and national labor legislation.
Construction workers will be accommodated in dedicated worker accommodation facilities. While workforce welfare and accommodation requirements are referenced within existing corporate frameworks, project-specific worker accommodation arrangements and management requirements have not yet been fully developed. As part of the Contractor Labor Management Plan and applicable Construction ESMP requirements, the EPC contractor will develop and implement a Worker Accommodation Management Plan, consistent with IFC PS2 and the IFC/EBRD Workers' Accommodation Guidance Note. NZE will monitor implementation through its contractor management procedures and ESMS. [ESAP#2].
Workers’ Organizations: The existing labor management framework recognizes workers' rights to freedom of association, worker representation, collective bargaining, and labor dispute resolution in accordance with applicable Mongolian labor legislation and international labor standards. As part of ESAP#6, NZE will incorporate these commitments into project-level labor management procedures and contractor requirements.
Non-Discrimination and Equal Opportunity: The Employment and Labor Relations Policy prohibit discrimination based on race, ethnicity, language, age, gender, religion, disability, sexual orientation, union membership, family status, pregnancy, or other protected characteristics. The framework also includes provisions promoting gender equality, employment opportunities for women and persons with disabilities, and equal opportunities for career development. Under ESAP#6, NZE will develop and implement project-level non-discrimination and equal opportunity procedures consistent with IFC PS2 requirements. These procedures will also include fair treatment of migrant workers and measures to prevent and address workplace harassment, discrimination, gender-based violence and harassment (GBVH), retaliation, and other forms of workplace misconduct.
Grievance Mechanism: MCSI has established workforce grievance procedures that provide channels for workers to raise concerns relating to labor and working conditions, discrimination, occupational health and safety, workplace harassment, child labor, and trafficking in persons. The procedures include requirements for confidential handling, investigation, corrective actions, and escalation where required. Under ESAP#6, NZE will establish a project-specific worker grievance mechanism accessible to all direct and contracted workers. The mechanism will provide confidential, accessible, and non-retaliatory channels, including anonymous reporting options, for workers to raise workplace concerns and grievances. Information regarding the mechanism will be communicated through worker induction and ongoing training programs.
Occupational Health and Safety: The OHS risks associated with construction and operation activities include working at height, lifting operations, electrical works, BESS-related hazards, hazardous substances, and exposure to extreme climatic conditions. MCSI has established an Occupational Health and Safety Plan (OHSP) addressing OHS roles and responsibilities, risk assessment and permit-to-work systems, training and competency, management of high-risk activities, incident reporting, and monitoring. NZE will adopt a project-level OHSP as part of the project ESMS, including applicable requirements for contractors and subcontractors, consistent with PS2 and applicable WBG EHS Guidelines [ESAP#2].
Workers Engaged by Third Parties: MCSI’s labor framework includes requirements for contractor and subcontractor management, including compliance with labor, working conditions, non-discrimination, child labor, anti-harassment, and trafficking-in-persons requirements. Contractors and subcontractors are expected to implement labor management measures consistent with the applicable laws and project standards. As part of ESAP#6, NZE will develop and implement project-specific contractor and subcontractor labor management requirements and incorporate these obligations into EPC and subcontractor contractual arrangements. NZE will monitor contractor compliance through its contractor management procedures and ESMS.
PS3: Resource Efficiency and Pollution Prevention:
The project is estimated to generate 487,123 MWh per year, with greenhouse gas emission reductions of 599,008 tCO2 equivalents per year.
Based on the project ESIA, the estimated total water consumption during the 17-month construction phase is approximately 111,397 m³. This volume includes water required for dust suppression, road compaction, domestic use for the workforce, and concrete works. All construction water will be sourced from off-site licensed municipal suppliers in Tsogttsetsii and trucked to the site.
Given extreme Gobi seasonal variations, NZE will develop and implement a comprehensive Water Management Plan prior to construction [ESAP #2]. This plan will incorporate a source sustainability review to confirm that extraction will not impact third-party water access and define strict water recycling and efficiency measures. Operational water use is expected to be negligible.
The project is expected to generate minor pollution to air, water, and soil, which are anticipated to be readily mitigated through the implementation of standard pollution prevention and control measures defined within the project ESMP.
During operation, replaced electronic components and cooling fluids will be collected and disposed of as hazardous/e-waste by a licensed contractor. Spent battery units will be segregated and dispatched to specialized recycling facilities located in Siirst bagh (Tsogttsetsii), Bayan bagh (Khanbogd), or licensed facilities in Ulaanbaatar.
Shadow flicker is assessed not to be a significant risk. Noise from construction activities is not expected to be a significant issue for this project, as there are limited nearby sensitive receptors and construction activities will be limited to daylight hours. An assessment of operational noise impacts was completed as part of the ESIA using predictive modelling, which concluded that potentially significant effects on sensitive receptors are not anticipated. To verify these modelled noise levels and ensure compliance with WBG EHS guidelines in the sensitive Gobi landscape, NZE will conduct noise compliance testing at representative herder winter settlements immediately upon the start of operations [ESAP #2]. If this operational monitoring identifies any noise exceedances, appropriate mitigation measures will be implemented. Additionally, if an alternate turbine is selected differing from the Envision model assessed in the ESIA, NZE shall conduct a supplementary noise assessment specific to that turbine model prior to installation.
PS4: Community Health, Safety and Security:
Community Health and Safety: The project may result in community health and safety risks primarily associated with construction traffic and transportation of oversized equipment, workforce-community interactions, communicable diseases, and emergency events. Relevant mitigation measures have been identified in the ESIA and ESMP and existing MCSI management frameworks, including traffic management, emergency preparedness and response, worker code of conduct, community awareness and grievance arrangements, and measures to manage GBVH risks.
As part of the project ESMP and ESMS, NZE will adopt a project-specific Community Health, Safety and Security Management Plan (CHSSMP), building on the existing frameworks and incorporating relevant ESIA and ESMP requirements, including the Traffic Management Plan, EPRP, and Security Management Plan, consistent with PS4 and applicable WBG EHS Guidelines. The CHSSMP and supporting plans will address community traffic and road safety, workforce-community interactions, including GBVH and communicable disease risks, community emergency preparedness and response, management of security personnel and interactions with local communities; community engagement and grievance management; and monitoring and corrective actions. [ESAP#2].
Security Personnel: The project will engage security personnel whose activities may involve interactions with local communities and herders. A MCSI-level Security Service Procedure has been developed addressing personnel requirements and vetting, access control, use of force, community interface, prohibited conduct and incident reporting. The project will incorporate applicable security management requirements into the project-level Security Management Plan under the CHSSMP and project ESMS [ESAP#2].
Shadow flicker. The ESIA assessed shadow flickers at 11 sensitive receptors within the 1,820 m Area of Influence, of which four are predicted to experience measurable shadow flickers. The modeling identified only one receptor (an unoccupied temporary summer camp at the time of survey) exceeding the applicable daily guideline under the conservative worst-case scenario (35 minutes/day), although remaining below the annual guideline (27.3 hours/year). Under the real-case scenario, all assessed receptors are predicted to comply with applicable guidelines. Shadow flicker monitoring and management measures will be incorporated into the project ESMP and ESMS, including monitoring of affected receptors and community grievances and implementation of appropriate corrective measures where project-related impacts are identified. [ESAP#2].
PS5: Land Acquisition and Involuntary Resettlement:
The project will require temporary and permanent occupation of land that is predominantly used as grazing land by local herder households. The ESIA estimates that approximately 25.11 ha will be temporarily disturbed during construction and approximately 105.2 ha will be permanently occupied by project infrastructure, including WTG foundations and hardstands, internal and OHL access roads, the substation and BESS, and OHL towers.
Land in Mongolia is state-owned, while herders use pasture under a combination of formal rights associated with seasonal camps and customary or open-access grazing arrangements. Based on the project layout and field verification, the project footprint is not expected to directly affect identified residential structures, winter or spring camps, wells, or other residential facilities, and no physical displacement is expected. The project will, however, result in economic displacement through temporary and permanent loss of, or restricted access to, grazing land and potential disruption of livestock movement during construction and operation.
The ESIA identified 22 project-affected households associated with structures within the project area and/or near the OHL alignment. Based on the current footprint and available land-use information, 16 households are expected to experience permanent loss of access to portions of grazing land, while additional households may experience temporary impacts during construction. Temporary impacts will be localized and phased, generally lasting approximately one month for affected WTG-area households, with disturbed areas reinstated following construction. In addition, the project area may also be used periodically by seasonal and customary pasture users who are not associated with identified structures or formal land rights. The ESIA indicates that the area of grazing land affected represents a small proportion of the broader grazing resources used by affected households and that grazing will remain possible across much of the project area during operation.
As part of the ESIA, the project has prepared a Livelihood Restoration Framework (LRF) that establishes initial principles for eligibility, entitlements, implementation, grievance management, monitoring, roles, responsibilities, and budget. Under ESAP#7, NZE will develop and implement a Livelihood Restoration Plan (LRP) consistent with PS5 based on the final project footprint and completed census and socioeconomic assessment. The LRP will establish the final affected population, eligibility and cut-off date; assess temporary and permanent economic displacement at household level; establish an entitlement matrix and compensation methodology; define livelihood restoration measures; address vulnerable households and formal, informal, seasonal and customary users; and establish consultation, grievance, implementation, monitoring and livelihood restoration completion arrangements.
PS6: Biodiversity Conservation and Sustainable Management of Living Natural Resources:
The Project is located within the Central Asian Gobi Desert Ecoregion which consists of cold desert and semi-desert ecosystems. Desert steppe habitats dominate the landscape which consists of low sparse shrubs that are interspersed with Saxaul forests, intermittent riverbeds, and rocky outcrops. The ecoregion has been significantly modified by grazing activities. The Asiatic Wild Ass (Equus hemionus) IUCN Near Threatened and Goitered Gazelle (Gazella subgutturosa) IUCN Vulnerable populations also occur within the ecoregion.
The Project will be constructed in an area dominated by natural rangeland habitats. Three locally protected areas are transversed by the transmission line by the project, including the Gurvan gavluud, Har deliin tolgod and Ih Baga Luus protected areas. According to Mongolian laws, the Project is permissible within these areas. There is no management plan currently prepared for the areas.
Avifaunal baseline surveys conducted identified several important species, including Saker falcon Falco cherrug IUCN Endangered, Steppe eagle Aquilla nipalensis IUCN Endangered, Cinereous vulture Aegypius monachus IUCN Near Threatened as well as migratory species including Whooper swan Cygnus cygnus IUCN Least Concern. Two IUCN Least Concern bat species were also detected. Other fauna values identified include Asiatic Wild Ass (E. hemionus) and Goitered Gazelle (G. subgutturosa). Flora surveys identified two conservation significant plants including Amygdalus mongolica Endangered and Tugarinovia mongolica Vulnerable under the Mongolian Red List of Plants. Four additional plants are described as rare under Mongolian classifications. None of these species are considered to trigger critical habitat.
Impacts to biodiversity values due to project operations and construction have been assessed. Collision risk modeling for avifauna indicates that three species identified as heightened risk from turbine and transmission line collision, including Saker falcon, Cinereous vulture and Upland buzzard Buteo hemilasius IUCN Least Concern. The total permanently disturbed area of natural habitat by the project footprint is estimated at approximately 66.56 hectares to which no-net-loss will apply. Impacts to threatened flora values during construction and invasive species introduction from importing materials and equipment are possible.
To manage these risks, the ESMS [see ESAP #2 and ESAP 9] will manage risks from construction activities, including preserving threatened plants, reducing impacts from transport and the workforce, design of the transmission line to reduce electrocution risks and the installation of bird flight diverters along the transmission line A Framework Biodiversity Action Plan (BAP) has been prepared that outlines requirements for operational management, including the implementation of a Post Construction Fatality Monitoring (PCFM) strategy to understand risks to avifauna and implementation of adaptive management strategies if required, including the potential use of Shut-Down on Demand [ESAP #10]. The final BAP will be prepared that will include the biodiversity offset management plan to compensate for the loss of natural habitat and operation within protected areas. NZE will be required to finalize the BAP prior to operation [ESAP #8].
PS8: Cultural Heritage:
An archaeological survey undertaken in August 2024 did not identify archaeological or cultural heritage within the surveyed WTG area. The ESIA also assessed known cultural heritage through desktop review, field surveys and community consultation, including ovoos in the wider project area and a tomb located approximately 305 m from the OHL. The nearest identified ovoo is approximately 660 m from WTG No. 20. While the tomb is not included in the official list of historical and cultural heritage sites, consultations with local authorities and communities did not identify cultural, spiritual or customary significance, custodianship, or associated cultural practices. Based on the assessment, no significant impacts on known cultural heritage are anticipated.
The project has developed a Chance Find Procedure (CFP), including procedures for responding to chance finds and specific provisions for human remains. The CFP will be incorporated into the Project ESMS [ESAP #2] and applicable contractor management requirements and implemented during construction and other ground-disturbing activities in accordance with PS8 and applicable national requirements. Consultation with relevant authorities and communities will be undertaken where project activities could affect culturally significant sites or associated cultural practices.